Michigan

FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION
Bretton Barber wore a T-shirt to Dearborn High School in Michigan with a picture of President Bush and the caption "International Terrorist." The 16-year-old student was told he should take off the shirt or go home.  He refused to remove the shirt and left school.  He filed a federal free speech lawsuit with the help of the ACLU, and won his case in October 2003, with the district court judge stating that "there is no evidence that the T-shirt created any disturbance or disruption" at school.  The judge also rejected the school district's position that school is an inappropriate place for political debate, maintaining that on the contrary, "students benefit when school officials provide an environment where they can openly express their diverging viewpoints and when they learn to tolerate the opinions of others."

FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION
In November 2003, Alexander Smith was largely – but not entirely – victorious in the lawsuit he brought after he was suspended for 10 days from Pleasant High School for reading aloud to friends at his lunch table a commentary criticizing the school's new tardiness policy and calling the school principal and assistant principal names.  The judge ruled that the Michigan state law which required the suspension or expulsion of students who engaged in a "verbal assault" in school was, as Smith had claimed, unconstitutional.  But the judge also said administrators had the right to discipline the student because of the "vicious and personal" names he had called school officials. 

DISCRIMINATION
In early 2006 the mother of the only Black student at a school in Frankfurt , Michigan filed a lawsuit on behalf of her daughter, stating that school administrators had forced the third grader to use a separate restroom and other students had taunted her with racial slurs. 

FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION
After a federal district court in March 2007 ruled on behalf of Jefferson Middle School students, they will be allowed to engage in a silent protest against abortion.  One student had been prohibited from wearing a pro-life T-shirt and covering his mouth with tape as part of the Pro-Life Day of Silent Solidarity.  In its decision, the court referred to the 1969 Supreme Court Tinker decision, which upholds student expression unless it creates a substantial disruption in the school or invade the rights of others.  The school district is appealing to the US Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit.